Tony Abbott. Not a disaster at all. Seriously.

E-mail Print
Tony AbbottAfter the leadership spill last year Miranda Devine declared that “the women of the twitterverse, the ABC and Crikey.com agreed Abbott's election was a disaster”.

A disaster? Maybe, but not one without an amusing side. Tony Abbot as PM would indeed be disastrous, but Tony Abbot as the leader of the opposition could prove to be quite a boon for the nation, if not for the government.

 Abbot is many things, quite a few of them unpleasant and most of them listed in the Manual of Mental Disorders; but even his greatest detractors would have to concede that he does not suffer from the sort of mealy-mouthed offensively-inoffensive verbosity that stifles so many other politicians. And as mad as the monk may be, he is as at least as intelligent as Turnbull and far, far more experienced with the ludicrous political machinations of Canberran politics.

Abbott, arguing staunch policy from the right, could force the government into articulating a much clearer stance, not just on climate change, but on issues like gay marriage, asylum seekers, education, health care and tax reform. Rudd has, until now, been meeting the opposition in the middle and fighting them over the decimal points, with the status quo being the only goal anyone aims for. In polarising debate over key issues, Abbott may finally push Rudd off so many of the fences he’s been clinging to.

In all the hyperbole over the failure of the ETS it is easy to lose sight of the fact that it was a highly ineffective piece of legislation, so much so that it united the Greens and the Minchinites against it. Rudd’s attempt to appease the coal industry, without conceding an inch of the high moral ground, resulted in an ETS framework that would have created a huge drag on the economy, while handing out windfalls for polluters and doing nothing to reduce carbon emissions.

With no effective opposition, the government was able to ignore the Greens demands for a genuinely effective ETS, and negotiate only with a compliant opposition. Abbott may not be able to come up with a viable alternative to an ETS, but while he stands firm on refusing to allow the “great big tax on everything” to go through, he may end up forcing the government to do it for him.

Whether they go to a Double Dissolution or not, another election is unlikely to give the government control in the senate, and they will have no choice but to reach a compromise deal with either the Greens or a truly conservative coalition.

It’s difficult to make accurate predictions in the current rapidly changing political environment, but there does look to be a clear opportunity for the Greens to pick up protest votes from moderate liberals in a climate change election. A more powerful Green voice and pressure from the voters to take action on climate change, combined with increasing industry demands for a market based solution and the need for certainty on how the carbon issue will be addressed, will ensure that doing nothing is not an option. In the face of this even the Rudd government would find it difficult to convince the voters that an intransigent coalition was the reason for their lack of action.

An Abbott led coalition, by polarising opinion on climate change, could actually be the impetus for genuine and effective action led by the Rudd government and the Greens.

Wouldn’t that be a truly worthwhile legacy for the Mad Monk?

Comments (0)
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Gravatar enabled
Comment:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img]   
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."

 

Daily Shout

Election 2010

Jane Shaw
ballotElection time! Which means every media hound in the country is straining at the leash like a corgi in heat. Here at the Tribune, we’ve decided that there’s very little point...
More

The Misery Of Sport

Justin Shaw
burgerThere is very little in sport that has made me happy lately. And it may surprise you to know that, from time to time, I like being happy. And I miss...
More

Hey! ABC! Get Your Arse Into Gear!

Jane Shaw
ABC_logo_arseI’m a rampant media consumer, way too much of the time I should spend being productive I am instead wandering around the internet reading about stuff. Politics and religion and sex...
More

Jason Akermanis - homophobe or gay activist?

Jane Shaw
akermanisAnother storm in a media teacup ysterday. Jason Akermanis, who doesn’t appear to hate publicity, wrote a column in the Herald Sun, who also don’t appear to hate courting controversy, saying...
More

Our Proud Broadsheet

Luke T
I'm no journo, but this much I know: newspapers come in two types, broadsheets and tabloids. Generally, broadsheets have produce higher quality reporting than tabloids, which tend toward more sensationalism and...
More

Lest We Presume

Luke T
There is a point in everyone’s almanac where they admit defeat on summer’s behalf and embrace winter. The scarves and jackets are retrieved from the cupboard above the wardrobe, and the...
More

Some Stuff About Earthquakes

Jane Shaw
wingnutsThe people from the internet have been wailing and hand wringing  about how all the recent earthquakes were caused by Mother Earth being all mad and getting her revenge on.Most of...
More

Justin Bieber

Jane Shaw
Justin BeiberOk, I know I’m a little late coming to the WTF party on this, but let’s overlook that and just embrace the fact that I’m almost 40 and I still bothered...
More

Sporting Shouting

Justin Shaw
meterWell I’m so grateful to Fremantle for showing me the error of my ways.Having advised you to Never Ever Tip Freo, they’re unbeaten after three rounds, achieving their last over the...
More

Abbot, Greer and Vaginas (now SFW)

Jane Shaw
Tony AbbottIt’s been an interesting week in the whirligig of fun that constitutes my understanding of feminism. Tony Abbott came out in favour of paid maternity leave! I get that he’s chasing...
More
Read more shouts

 



Contribute to The Kings Tribune

Become part of the Tribune, not for filthy lucre (we don’t have any) but just for the fun of infamy. Plus you get full bragging rights about how you got published, not just on the internets (anyone can do that) but on actual old fashioned PAPER.

Get more details here and then get writing, drawing or rhyming and show the world what you got. Send submissions or questions to editors@kingstribune.com 



In This Month's  Magazine...

Editors Rant - June 2010

June 2010
J&J Shaw
editorsNo matter how hard Kevin Rudd tries to lose the next election, the Coalition keep handing him big plates of gold. Abbott admitted to being, effectively, a compulsive liar. Joe Hockey...
Read more...

Come Back Senator Humphries

June 2010
Scott Anderson
Senator HumphriesWow hasn’t sexuality and in particular which side of the fence you are on become a hot topic of late! First up, on my right, we have the thinking man’s meathead,...
Read more...

Eating Animals in Australia

June 2010
Jane Shaw
sheepI’m a right-wing, red-wine-guzzling carnivore. I have even been known, after guzzling a few red wines, to rant about how vegetarianism is an eating disorder. So writing about the evils of...
Read more...

Why I’m not a Christian

June 2010
Chris Howe
After attending a reasonably funny, thought-provoking and interesting talk called “Laugh your way to a better marriage” I was feeling pretty good. Six hours over two nights away from the kids...
Read more...

Dirty Deed - The Clean Feed Filter

June 2010
Zoe Beaumont
kangaroosThere’s a great deal of debate going on right now over mandatory internet filtering, or the “Clean Feed” proposed recently by our PM, Mr Illustrious KRudd.I’ve been happily coughing curse words...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries - June 2010

June 2010
The Winderlich Dad
Bruce WillisThe weather’s cold and pissy. So is Wife, because, cheap horrible cruel bastard that I am, I won’t tolerate the thermostat being set to “the heart of the sun”, instead suggesting...
Read more...

Burning Effegies – part II

June 2010
Justin Shaw
Jack RushThe Bushfires Royal Commission has heard final submissions and will deliver its final report to the Governor on July 31. Should the Commissioners accept the thrust of what Counsel Assisting, Jack...
Read more...

Displacement Activities for the Almost 40s

June 2010
Jane Shaw
dress patternSo, I’m going to be 40 in a couple of weeks, and I’m not taking it well. Not at all. Drunkenly ranting at my husband about the lost opportunities of my...
Read more...

Dave Graney at the Butterfly Club

June 2010
Justin Shaw
Dave GraneyDave Graney isn’t a musician that you like, or love, or even get. Dave, you can only dig, and I really dig the Dave. From the first time I heard his...
Read more...

The Tony Horror Picture Show

June 2010
Jane Shaw
tony abbott picture showI’m fairly sure I’ve said it before, but for anyone who had more interesting things to read that day, I’ll say it again. I’m a right wing (small L) liberal. I...
Read more...

 



Anecdotage

The Winderlich Diaries - June 2010

The Winderlich Dad
Bruce WillisThe weather’s cold and pissy. So is Wife, because, cheap horrible cruel bastard that I am, I won’t tolerate the thermostat being set to “the heart of the sun”, instead suggesting...
Read more...

Displacement Activities for the Almost 40s

Jane Shaw
dress patternSo, I’m going to be 40 in a couple of weeks, and I’m not taking it well. Not at all. Drunkenly ranting at my husband about the lost opportunities of my...
Read more...

A Short History of Arses

Jane Shaw
bottomNo, this is not a short history of all the arses I have known. Firstly, that wouldn’t be short, and secondly, I don’t like having bricks thrown through my window. This...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries - May 2010

The Winderlich Boy
Dad’s always at me to get the hell away from the Xbox and go outside. Outside sucks. How can I yell “W00t, noob, you are so pwned!!!” at someone outside? There’s...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries – April 2010

The Dog
black dogThere’s Cat. I could chase her. I really should chase her, but there are no humans around to suck up to. So I’m looking at Cat, and she’s looking back at...
Read more...

The Scaffoldist

Mat Larkin
‘The thing is,’ says Oscar, draining his coffee, ‘is that the British one pound coin is very thick, and around the edge it has something written in Latin.’‘Right,’ I say.‘Or Welsh.’...
Read more...

A Telstra of a Mess

The Not Drowning Mother
Let’s get this straight: Telstra came to me. I did not go to Telstra.I was simply minding my own business when a cheerful Telstra representative gave me a courtesy call informing...
Read more...

A Cautionary Tale

Jane Shaw
fail of the machinesSo, everyone familiar with the Tribune will notice that we are now printing in colour. Doesn’t it look lovely? Notice the colour artwork people, appreciate it, maybe even sniff it a...
Read more...

Funny Old Thing, Life

Miranda V
weddingI have recently come to the conclusion that having too many options can be a bad thing. As I sit here, a blustery and rainy Melbourne day thrashing about outside, I...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries - Feb 2010

Mr Winderlich
not funnyWell we survived the Christmas dinner with my appalling in-laws. Just after we’d finished making jokes about how much fun it was going to be doing it next year with my...
Read more...
Read more anecdotes

Main Menu

Current Issue

Election 2010

Tribune Ezine

Enter your name and email address, then click SUBSCRIBE to recieve The King's Tribune Mag via email each month.
Kings Tribune


Receive HTML?

Find Us On Facebook

Facebook Link

Follow Us On Twitter

Facebook Link

KT Tweets

An error occurred

Oops, an error seems to have occurred. We're sorry for any inconvenience this might have caused. If the error persists, feel free to tell us about it.

Tribune Classifieds

Sponsors