The Balibo Five - Our Shame, The Australian's Agenda

E-mail Print
balibo posterThe story of the Balibo 5, Australia-based journalists murdered by Indonesian troops in 1975, and the subsequent murder of another Australian journalist, Roger East, is the subject of a new film by Robert Connolly. (I haven’t seen it yet, but I plan to in the next couple of days, and will write a review either here or in the September Tribune). Before I've even seen it, however, I've had cause to get Very Angry.

I have to disclose an interest here: I know someone who is deeply involved, so my anger is somewhat greater than usual. I’ll try to keep this vaguely sensible, but I urge you to do some follow-up reading.

Today, Saturday August 15th, in The Australian (links at the bottom of this article) are two pieces on the subject. One is a film review by Evan Williams, who, conveniently for The Australian’s unendingly pro-Indonesia stance, was a Whitlam staffer at the time of the murders. Why let objectivity get in the way of your owner’s agenda? The other is a story by Caroline Overington regarding repatriation of the 5’s remains for possible DNA analysis. 

Let’s go with Overington’s bit first, remembering at all times that The Australian appears to be the leak-ee of choice for the AFP (terrorism raids last week, batting for the AFP over their disgraceful, politically-motivated prosecution of Dr Haneef etc etc etc).

She quotes the AFP as saying that the families of the murdered journalists are to blame for delays in their investigation, because the families supposedly can't agree on repatriation of the journalists' remains. Apparently the remains are so crucial that the investigation can't move forward without them.

The Inquest heard from a large number of eyewitnesses, and with all the evidence before it, the Court found that the Balibo 5 were, in fact, dead, and that they had, in fact, been murdered by Indonesian troops. Do we really need to repatriate what amounts to not much more than a shoebox full of dirt and ashes, and put it through DNA testing to the mitochondrial level, to be satisfied that they are dead? It’s not like they disappeared into the jungle and have been living a Colonel Kurtz existence for the last thirty-four years.

However, fabricating a delay beyond their control on this non-issue serves the AFP’s purpose, and Overington happily gives them the column inches and the bald headline.

The AFP have sat on this for nearly two years (it was referred to them formally in Jan 2008) . They did not make any contact with the families at all; family enquiries of the AFP had to go through DFAT, who would relay a "we'll investigate and get back to you". In September 2008 the AFP were about to have a meeting on repatriation with the A-G’s office and DFAT, but cancelled it due to everyone having the flu, and they have not, to my knowledge, met in any meaningful way on the subject since.

The only contact the AFP initiated with the families was a letter sent to each of them a few days before the film’s premiere at the Melbourne International Film Festival.

The extent of the AFP’s investigation of these war crimes appears to have been to prepare press releases that will shine the best possible light on themselves and, as usual, blame others for their own inaction.

On to the second article that got me mad: Evan Williams’  film review.

Most of it is luke-warm-to-positive on the film itself, but once the review wanders into what the film actually means for us and our previous governments, it suddenly gets surreal. As I said, Williams was a Whitlam staffer at the time of the murders, so, like the loathsome Richard Woolcott, he has a legacy to protect.

East Timor was a Portuguese colony until 1975. Portugal was a very poor colonial master, and, when it was time to go, put no effort into establishing some kind of government or even law for the people to get along with once they left. All this is true, but it is an extremely long, and sick-making bow to draw, for Williams to say that “The real villain of 1975 was Portugal”. I don’t believe it was Portuguese troops invading and murdering civilians and Australian journalists, I think that was actually Indonesia, wasn’t it?

This is like saying the biggest villain in the Rwandan genocides was Rwanda’s old colonial boss Belgium – it wasn’t Belgians rounding up and killing thousands of civilians, and it certainly wasn’t Belgium sitting around at the UN threatening to possibly send a strongly-worded letter in a fortnight’s time.

The villains in East Timor’s tragedy are Soeharto’s Indonesia, and the Western nations that sat on their hands and appeased him.

For Williams to say that the view of Australia (and every other Western government) was that the best thing for East Timor was “incorporation with Indonesia after a short period of self-determination” is to ignore the fact that this opinion was held while the Vietnam War was just fizzling out, but the fear that had caused it (communist influence in Asia) was still running strong. There was also, of course, the matter of huge oil and gas reserves in the Timor Sea, and the potential for exploiting them with a friendly dictatorship. So, desperately eager to prop up the bloodthirsty Soharto on the “he might be a son of a bitch, but he’s our son of a bitch” principle, the West went scurrying around appeasing the vicious bastard, quick to sign whatever treaties with him they could, and make some bucks out of his corruption.

Another of Williams' complaints is that Australia sent troops to East Timor in 1999, and the film doesn’t mention that at all. I didn’t realise that a film had to congratulate John Howard to get more than three stars. But that’s The Australian for you.

Check out the movie poster attached to this Shout – the quotes in it are from our own Dear Leader Kevin. They polled well at the time, but I guess he’s had other priorities since then. Probably the same priorities that have made it too difficult to respond to emails or letters from the families asking when anything is going to be done, or even said.

Lots of people have a lot to answer for on this issue, and the thing that's making me furious is that no-one is answering anything. I think it's time they did.

More to come, once I’ve digested the Coronial findings, and gone through Overington's interview with Woolcott.

 

OVERINGTON:

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,25931566-601,00.html

WILLIAMS:

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,25914564-15803,00.html

Comments (3)
  • Kate Milkins  - Quality journalism at last
    avatar
    :) Thanks for a well written and researched article Justin. I wish there could be more intelligent information like this available in our major daily papers. As a first time Tribune reader I am impressed and will be reading it in the future! cheers, Kate M
  • juzzy  - cheers
    avatar
    thanks Kate, glad it hit the spot. I'm working on a much larger piece for the next issue (but probably the one after that, truth be told)...
    Please pass it around to all your peeps if you haven't already, and get yourself on our email list, too!
    Was very unimpressed with Overington's little clarification piece yesterday, particularly given that she got John's name wrong AGAIN!!!

  • Scotty
    avatar
    I just love that final sentence in Overington's article. It's just gorgeous that the Indonesian government are claiming the entire doco is fiction. The only organisation in the world that claims the '75 invasion's various atrocities are fiction is the same organisation that perpetrated them.
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Gravatar enabled
Comment:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img]   
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."

 

Daily Shout

Election 2010

Jane Shaw
ballotElection time! Which means every media hound in the country is straining at the leash like a corgi in heat. Here at the Tribune, we’ve decided that there’s very little point...
More

The Misery Of Sport

Justin Shaw
burgerThere is very little in sport that has made me happy lately. And it may surprise you to know that, from time to time, I like being happy. And I miss...
More

Hey! ABC! Get Your Arse Into Gear!

Jane Shaw
ABC_logo_arseI’m a rampant media consumer, way too much of the time I should spend being productive I am instead wandering around the internet reading about stuff. Politics and religion and sex...
More

Jason Akermanis - homophobe or gay activist?

Jane Shaw
akermanisAnother storm in a media teacup ysterday. Jason Akermanis, who doesn’t appear to hate publicity, wrote a column in the Herald Sun, who also don’t appear to hate courting controversy, saying...
More

Our Proud Broadsheet

Luke T
I'm no journo, but this much I know: newspapers come in two types, broadsheets and tabloids. Generally, broadsheets have produce higher quality reporting than tabloids, which tend toward more sensationalism and...
More

Lest We Presume

Luke T
There is a point in everyone’s almanac where they admit defeat on summer’s behalf and embrace winter. The scarves and jackets are retrieved from the cupboard above the wardrobe, and the...
More

Some Stuff About Earthquakes

Jane Shaw
wingnutsThe people from the internet have been wailing and hand wringing  about how all the recent earthquakes were caused by Mother Earth being all mad and getting her revenge on.Most of...
More

Justin Bieber

Jane Shaw
Justin BeiberOk, I know I’m a little late coming to the WTF party on this, but let’s overlook that and just embrace the fact that I’m almost 40 and I still bothered...
More

Sporting Shouting

Justin Shaw
meterWell I’m so grateful to Fremantle for showing me the error of my ways.Having advised you to Never Ever Tip Freo, they’re unbeaten after three rounds, achieving their last over the...
More

Abbot, Greer and Vaginas (now SFW)

Jane Shaw
Tony AbbottIt’s been an interesting week in the whirligig of fun that constitutes my understanding of feminism. Tony Abbott came out in favour of paid maternity leave! I get that he’s chasing...
More
Read more shouts

 



Contribute to The Kings Tribune

Become part of the Tribune, not for filthy lucre (we don’t have any) but just for the fun of infamy. Plus you get full bragging rights about how you got published, not just on the internets (anyone can do that) but on actual old fashioned PAPER.

Get more details here and then get writing, drawing or rhyming and show the world what you got. Send submissions or questions to editors@kingstribune.com 



In This Month's  Magazine...

Editors Rant - June 2010

June 2010
J&J Shaw
editorsNo matter how hard Kevin Rudd tries to lose the next election, the Coalition keep handing him big plates of gold. Abbott admitted to being, effectively, a compulsive liar. Joe Hockey...
Read more...

Come Back Senator Humphries

June 2010
Scott Anderson
Senator HumphriesWow hasn’t sexuality and in particular which side of the fence you are on become a hot topic of late! First up, on my right, we have the thinking man’s meathead,...
Read more...

Eating Animals in Australia

June 2010
Jane Shaw
sheepI’m a right-wing, red-wine-guzzling carnivore. I have even been known, after guzzling a few red wines, to rant about how vegetarianism is an eating disorder. So writing about the evils of...
Read more...

Why I’m not a Christian

June 2010
Chris Howe
After attending a reasonably funny, thought-provoking and interesting talk called “Laugh your way to a better marriage” I was feeling pretty good. Six hours over two nights away from the kids...
Read more...

Dirty Deed - The Clean Feed Filter

June 2010
Zoe Beaumont
kangaroosThere’s a great deal of debate going on right now over mandatory internet filtering, or the “Clean Feed” proposed recently by our PM, Mr Illustrious KRudd.I’ve been happily coughing curse words...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries - June 2010

June 2010
The Winderlich Dad
Bruce WillisThe weather’s cold and pissy. So is Wife, because, cheap horrible cruel bastard that I am, I won’t tolerate the thermostat being set to “the heart of the sun”, instead suggesting...
Read more...

Burning Effegies – part II

June 2010
Justin Shaw
Jack RushThe Bushfires Royal Commission has heard final submissions and will deliver its final report to the Governor on July 31. Should the Commissioners accept the thrust of what Counsel Assisting, Jack...
Read more...

Displacement Activities for the Almost 40s

June 2010
Jane Shaw
dress patternSo, I’m going to be 40 in a couple of weeks, and I’m not taking it well. Not at all. Drunkenly ranting at my husband about the lost opportunities of my...
Read more...

Dave Graney at the Butterfly Club

June 2010
Justin Shaw
Dave GraneyDave Graney isn’t a musician that you like, or love, or even get. Dave, you can only dig, and I really dig the Dave. From the first time I heard his...
Read more...

The Tony Horror Picture Show

June 2010
Jane Shaw
tony abbott picture showI’m fairly sure I’ve said it before, but for anyone who had more interesting things to read that day, I’ll say it again. I’m a right wing (small L) liberal. I...
Read more...

 



Anecdotage

The Winderlich Diaries - June 2010

The Winderlich Dad
Bruce WillisThe weather’s cold and pissy. So is Wife, because, cheap horrible cruel bastard that I am, I won’t tolerate the thermostat being set to “the heart of the sun”, instead suggesting...
Read more...

Displacement Activities for the Almost 40s

Jane Shaw
dress patternSo, I’m going to be 40 in a couple of weeks, and I’m not taking it well. Not at all. Drunkenly ranting at my husband about the lost opportunities of my...
Read more...

A Short History of Arses

Jane Shaw
bottomNo, this is not a short history of all the arses I have known. Firstly, that wouldn’t be short, and secondly, I don’t like having bricks thrown through my window. This...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries - May 2010

The Winderlich Boy
Dad’s always at me to get the hell away from the Xbox and go outside. Outside sucks. How can I yell “W00t, noob, you are so pwned!!!” at someone outside? There’s...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries – April 2010

The Dog
black dogThere’s Cat. I could chase her. I really should chase her, but there are no humans around to suck up to. So I’m looking at Cat, and she’s looking back at...
Read more...

The Scaffoldist

Mat Larkin
‘The thing is,’ says Oscar, draining his coffee, ‘is that the British one pound coin is very thick, and around the edge it has something written in Latin.’‘Right,’ I say.‘Or Welsh.’...
Read more...

A Telstra of a Mess

The Not Drowning Mother
Let’s get this straight: Telstra came to me. I did not go to Telstra.I was simply minding my own business when a cheerful Telstra representative gave me a courtesy call informing...
Read more...

A Cautionary Tale

Jane Shaw
fail of the machinesSo, everyone familiar with the Tribune will notice that we are now printing in colour. Doesn’t it look lovely? Notice the colour artwork people, appreciate it, maybe even sniff it a...
Read more...

Funny Old Thing, Life

Miranda V
weddingI have recently come to the conclusion that having too many options can be a bad thing. As I sit here, a blustery and rainy Melbourne day thrashing about outside, I...
Read more...

The Winderlich Diaries - Feb 2010

Mr Winderlich
not funnyWell we survived the Christmas dinner with my appalling in-laws. Just after we’d finished making jokes about how much fun it was going to be doing it next year with my...
Read more...
Read more anecdotes

Main Menu

Current Issue

Tribune June 2010

Tribune Ezine

Enter your name and email address, then click SUBSCRIBE to recieve The King's Tribune Mag via email each month.
Kings Tribune


Receive HTML?

Find Us On Facebook

Facebook Link

Follow Us On Twitter

Facebook Link

Tribune Classifieds

Sponsors